Alzheimer’s: like I need a hole in the head.

By impactEDnurse • Jun 19th, 2009 • Category: ectopics

New Scientist reports on the work of neurophysiologist named Yuri Moskalenko who is proposing that people with Alzheimer’s disease may benefit from trepanation (the drilling of a small hole in the skull).

Trepanation has been practiced by various cultures for thousands of years to treat everything from schizophrenia to migraines to uncorking evil spirits trapped in the skull.
Today, removal of sections of skull is usually (but not always…. here is a little DIY trepanation) undertaken to release the build up of intercrainial pressure, following trauma or intercerebral bleeds.

Whilst the actual cause of Alzheimer’s is still being unravelled, there is evidence that decreased blood flow and a falling production of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) may be a significant agent.
CSF carries nutrients and removes waste products including tau and beta-amyloid proteins that may lead to plaque formation commonly found in the brains of people with Alzheimer’s.
As we age and our brain becomes less elastic or compliant, closing down the flow of blood and CSF.
By drilling a hole in the skull, pressure is relieved and the compliance increases:

Moskalenko studied 15 people who had undergone the procedure following head injuries. He found that their cranial compliance was around 20 per cent higher than the average for their age. Based on this, he calculates that a 4-square-centimetre hole increases cerebral blood flow by between 8 and 10 per cent, which is equivalent to 0.8 millilitres more blood per heartbeat (Human Physiology, vol 34, p 299). This, he says, shows that trepanation could be an effective treatment for Alzheimer’s, and he even goes so far as to suggest that it might provide a “significant” improvement in the mental functions of anyone from their mid-40s, when cranial compliance starts to decline.
A 4-square-centimetre hole increases cerebral blood flow by between 8 and 10 per cent.

Other scientists are exploring the use of spinal taps (lumbar punctures) to remove CSF volume as well a any accumulated toxins with some initial positive results.

Harriet Millward, deputy chief executive of UK-based charity Alzheimer’s Research Trust, is keeping an open mind. “The procedure has been understudied so far and, until further research has been undertaken, the possibility of beneficial effects remains open,” she says. David Smith, a neuropharmacologist and head of the Oxford Project to Investigate Memory and Ageing, is even more receptive. “I think the observations look pretty robust,” he says. In the absence of drug treatments for dementia, “these rather drastic surgical ones are worth considering”, he says.

You can read the entire article in New Scientist here.

impactEDnurse is also known as Ian Miller, a nurse with over 26 years experience working in a busy emergency department in, Australia. This site in no way reflects the opinions of that hospital. All stories (although based on actual experiences) have been changed to protect patient confidentiality.
Email this author | All posts by impactEDnurse

One Response »

  1. Hi, this is interesting findings by Pr.Moskolenko,as it points in the right direction in regards to brain trauma. I have studied many areas of health care as I have sucummed to a synscope over a year ago now and recognised there is a problem in my own day to day life style ,ie forgeting names,places etc. these problems where no doubt worse in the initial months following my collasp but have improoved somewhat upto present time(may have to do with daily exercise, diet etc changes)yet I am still not at the level (inteligence)as I was before the passout.my age 47,I have tried all the dogey and fake alternative therapys in the phone book and have had Zero results,only an emty wallet,I will try any thing once,but exercise and good food have lot to do, is the best alternative for myself.I would no doubt put my hand up as guinei pig for the professor`s work,anyway great article and my reference for came from the New scientist….thankyou,reagrds J.

Leave a Reply